Common Off-the-Plan Mistakes for Castle Hill Buyers

Five costly slip-ups first home buyers make when buying an apartment or townhouse off the plan, and how to plan around them.

Hero Image for Common Off-the-Plan Mistakes for Castle Hill Buyers

Buying off the plan in Castle Hill rewards a buyer who plans for settlement day, not just signing day.

Your contract may be signed well before the building is finished. Your finances, your lender's valuation and the rules for grants and duty can all be checked again later. This article covers the mistakes we see most often in a first home buyer's off-the-plan plans, so you can sort them out before you sign.

Mistake 1: Assuming the Contract Price Is the Value Your Lender Uses

Your lender works from its own valuation of the home, which can differ from the price on your contract. That matters because the loan and your deposit are measured against the valuation.

Under the Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme, for example, the deposit is a percentage of the home's value as assessed by the participating lender. A buyer who has saved more may also be asked to contribute more than the minimum. Both the price and the lender's valuation must sit at or below the price cap. For NSW that cap is $1,500,000 for the capital city and regional centres category, but the cap for your property depends on its suburb and postcode in Housing Australia's search tool. You can read more on our Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme page.

Consider a couple who sign a contract for an apartment, planning to use a 5% deposit. When the building completes, the valuation comes in below the contract price. They had kept a cash buffer beyond the minimum deposit and had checked their borrowing capacity with room to spare, so they covered the gap and settled on time. A couple with no buffer would have needed to find extra money at short notice. The trade-off is that holding a buffer means saving for longer before you sign.

Can First Home Buyers Defer Stamp Duty When Buying Off the Plan in NSW?

Yes. A NSW buyer purchasing off the plan to live in the home may defer transfer duty for up to 12 months. The deferral is not a reduction, so you still need the money when it falls due.

Duty is due at the earliest of 15 months after signing, settlement, or assignment of any part of the contract. The deferral is not available if any purchaser is a foreign person. For contracts exchanged on or after 1 July 2023, at least one purchaser must move in within 12 months after settlement and live there for at least 12 continuous months.

The separate First Home Buyers Assistance Scheme can cut the duty itself. Homes valued at $800,000 or less are exempt, and homes valued above $800,000 and below $1,000,000 pay a reduced rate. Revenue NSW publishes reduced duty of $9,796.75 at $850,000, against $32,437 of general duty. A solicitor or conveyancer lodges the claim after exchange. Our first home buyers page explains how stamp duty concessions fit into your overall budget.

Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at Quick Mortgage today.

Does the NSW First Home Owner Grant Apply to Off-the-Plan Homes?

It can. The NSW FHOG is $10,000 for newly built or off-the-plan homes, but the purchase price must be $600,000 or less.

Check the price test before you count the grant in your budget. One grant is payable per transaction. You must move in within 12 months of completion or purchase and live there for at least 12 continuous months, and you apply within 12 months of settlement. Neither you nor your spouse can have previously received an FHOG. The grant is not means tested, but it should not be the thing that decides whether the purchase works.

Why Help to Buy Often Does Not Suit Early-Stage Off-the-Plan Purchases

Help to Buy generally does not suit an apartment you are buying early in the build. For off-the-plan purchases, construction must have begun before you sign the contract, and settlement must occur within 90 days of final approval.

Help to Buy is a shared equity scheme. The Government contributes between 5% and 40% of a newly built home's price, and you need at least 2% of the price from savings. The trade-off is that the Government's share rises and falls with the property's value. You may also have to buy it back if your income stays above the threshold. From 1 July 2026 to 30 June 2027 the threshold is $103,000 for a single applicant and $165,000 for joint applicants. You also cannot combine it with the 5% Deposit Scheme. The NSW price cap for the capital city category is $1,300,000 under Help to Buy, lower than the $1,500,000 under the 5% scheme.

If you are comparing these options, a broker can help you map them against your home loan application.

Using the First Home Super Saver Scheme at the Wrong Time

The First Home Super Saver scheme must be used before ownership of the property transfers to you. Once it transfers, you can no longer ask the ATO for a determination.

Voluntary contributions of up to $15,000 a year and $50,000 in total count towards release. After you request release, it usually takes 15 to 20 business days for the money to reach you. For an off-the-plan contract where ownership transfers later, an ATO example shows the buyer requesting the determination, requesting release and notifying the ATO within 90 days after the contract date. If you miss the time limits, FHSS tax of 20% applies to the assessable released amount on top of income tax.

The trade-off is that the money is locked in super until released, and the released amount is taxed. Speak to your accountant about how this applies to you before you contribute.

Starting Pre-Approval Too Late for Your Settlement Date

Get pre-approval before you sign, and expect your lender to look at your finances again closer to settlement. Pre-approval shows your likely borrowing range, but it is not a promise that the loan will be there on settlement day.

If you save a bigger deposit or take on new debt between signing and settlement, your position can change. Off-the-plan projects can take a long time to complete, so your circumstances may change between signing and settlement. Keep your finances steady during that time and let your broker know about any changes early.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can first home buyers defer stamp duty off the plan in NSW?

Yes, a NSW buyer purchasing off the plan to live in the home may defer transfer duty for up to 12 months. Duty is then due at the earliest of 15 months after signing, settlement, or assignment of any part of the contract.

Does the NSW First Home Owner Grant cover off-the-plan homes?

It can. The grant is $10,000 for newly built or off-the-plan homes, but the purchase price must be $600,000 or less.

Why might the lender's valuation matter when buying off the plan?

Under the 5% Deposit Scheme, the deposit is a percentage of the home's value as assessed by the lender, which can differ from the purchase price. A lower valuation can mean you need more cash at settlement.

Can I use Help to Buy for any off-the-plan purchase?

Not usually. For off-the-plan purchases under Help to Buy, construction must have begun before you sign the contract, and settlement must occur within 90 days of final approval.


Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at Quick Mortgage today.